Mon 5 Jan 2009
Matt Smith cast in Doctor Who, internet explodes
Posted by liz under News, Television
No Comments
Over the weekend, the BBC announced the casting of the eleventh actor to play the Doctor: the relatively unknown Matt Smith. Trying to learn more about the latest star of British sci-fi epic may be more challenging than you think: typing “Matt Smith” into IMDB yields 41 results (hint: our boy is the fourth on the list). Though he’s had some exposure in the UK (in The Ruby in the Smoke and Party Animals) he’s a complete unknown to American fans. After head writer Steven Moffat had spoken about casting an older actor in the role, the appearance of Smith (at 26, the youngest yet) has caused tremendous outcry amongst the fans, whom, to put it politely, are concerned about the abilities of a younger actor to carry off the Doctor. (The words “boy band” seem to be tossed around frequently in these discussions, though at 26 Smith is positively ancient by boy band standards.)
To the doubters in the audience (and it’s not like there’s much in the way of acting credentials to sell us on him), I point you towards Smith’s interview with Doctor Who Confidential. Go on. Watch it. I’ll wait. Child-like enthusiasm aside, he won me over by the time he said, “What I did when I got the role… I paced around the room for about three days. Because I didn’t know what to do! So I’d just sort of get up, and then I’d come back, and I’d sit down, watch a bit of TV, and then I’d smile and go ‘I’m the Doctor.’”
Why? Because that’s exactly what I’d do in his place. It’s exactly what any Doctor Who fanboy or fangirl would do in his place. If nothing else, his evident enthusiasm for the role suggest he’s going to give the part everything he’s got. And for those doubting because of his age (I admit, I’ve gone through a bit of a mid-life crisis seeing someone younger than myself cast in the role), remember that…
- in 1974, 40-year-old Tom Baker was the youngest actor to take the role.
- in 1981, 29-year-old Peter Davison was the youngest actor to take the role (Davison only had 3 years on Smith, people!).
- not everyone appreciated the casting of Christopher Eccelston as the ninth Doctor: “He smells of Generation X apathy. I can’t think of anyone worse.”
- not everyone appreciated the casting of David Tennant as the tenth Doctor: “I have watched Doctor Who from the very first episode and am appalled at the way it is going.”
Will Matt Smith have the appropriate gravitas that so many seem to feel is necessary for the character of the Doctor? Until we’ve seen his first appearance in 2010, I don’t think we can safely say — but doesn’t a fellow fan at least deserve a chance?
But now that the eleventh Doctor’s casting is out of the way, we can focus on the important questions for the next season of Doctor Who, namely, who’s going to play the next companion?


Warner Bros. Studios continues to mine its DC Comics subsidiary for entertainment franchises. 
